scanned with a little interest.
1) Instead of the 6 day rule - give immediate forum priveledges and make them sit out the first alliance event - whenever that is. That should satisfy the intent of the waiting period while eliminating the pointlessness of what we were talking about.
2) Cap - Sure - I agree with it. Grandfather the current alliance members. I don't expect WDOA or MOD to cut people - but caps are good - but lower the minimum amount to not kill off alliances. 5 minimum - and 15 maximum for active. Then - lower the amount of inactives you are allowed to have to 3. Anymore than 3 and someone has to go. It stimulates alliance movement and in the end I think it makes the forums healthier as we would all get to know each other a little better. It also gets vets returning into different alliances. It would kill DBA and ttt in the current - but there's nothing stopping those coaches from returning to activity and reviving them - while in the meantime forcing them to another alliance where perhaps some more connections are made for future alliances.
In all - I think movement is healthy and stimulates parity.
Anyway - I'm probably a little off - but I like to offer different perspectives. Just my $0.02.